A Valuable Guide to Choosing the Perfect Running Shoe in NYC

JamesAnkles & Feet, Legs & Knees, Movement, RunningLeave a Comment

At James Fowler Physical Therapy, we are passionate about running. We want you to find the best shoe for your specific needs. Finding the right running shoe is crucial for maximizing comfort, preventing injuries, and enhancing your running experience. With the vibrant running culture in New York City, it’s essential to choose a shoe that suits your needs and the unique terrain of the city. This guide will provide valuable tips on selecting the perfect running shoe in NYC. 

1. Assess Your Foot Type

Understanding your foot type is essential as it determines the level of support and cushioning required. There are three basic foot types:  

  • Neutral Feet
    If your feet have a medium arch, you have a neutral foot type. Look for shoes with balanced cushioning and stability
  • Flat Feet
    If your arches are low or almost non-existent, you have flat feet. To support your feet, seek shoes that offer extra stability and motion control.
  • High Arches
    If you have high, pronounced arches, choose shoes with additional cushioning and flexibility

2. Determine Your Running Style

Identify your running style to select the appropriate shoe category.

  • Road Running
    For urban runners, lightweight and cushioned shoes with good traction are suitable
  • Trail Running
    If you enjoy off-road adventures, opt for trail-specific shoes that provide excellent grip, stability, and protection against uneven terrain

3. Visit a Specialty Running Store

Head to a specialty running store in NYC where experienced staff can guide you through the selection process. They will perform a gait analysis to assess your foot strike and help you find the right shoe for your specific needs. Popular stores in NYC include JackRabbit, Paragon Sports, and Super Runners Shop. 

4. Try on Shoes in the Afternoon

Feet tend to swell throughout the day, so it’s best to try on running shoes in the afternoon or evening when your feet are at their largest. This ensures a better fit and prevents discomfort during long runs.

5. Wear Appropriate Running Socks

Bring or wear the socks you typically use for running when trying on shoes. This allows you to gauge the fit accurately, as different sock thicknesses can affect how a shoe feels.

6. Focus on Comfort and Fit

Try on several different brands and models, considering the following factors:

  • Length and Width
    Ensure there’s a thumb’s width of space between your longest toe and the shoe’s tip. The shoe should snugly hold your foot without being too tight or loose.
  • Arch Support
    Look for a shoe that supports your foot’s natural arch.
  • Heel and Ankle Support
    Check for a secure fit around the heel and ankle to prevent slippage.
  • Flexibility
    The shoe should offer flexibility at the forefoot, allowing natural movement.

7. Test the Shoes

Take a few test strides or jog around the store to assess comfort, support, and overall performance. Pay attention to any pressure points or discomfort and trust your instincts. Shoes that immediately feel great immediately are more likely to provide long-term satisfaction.

8. Consider NYC Terrain and Weather

If you primarily run on concrete or pavement, choose shoes with ample cushioning to absorb impact. Additionally, consider weather conditions. If you run in wet or snowy conditions, look for shoes with good traction and water resistance.

9. Budget and Durability

Set a budget and consider the durability of the shoes. Running shoes generally last between 300-500 miles, so choose a shoe that aligns with your mileage goals. 

10. Reassess Regularly

As your running style and needs evolve, periodically reassess your shoe selection to ensure you’re getting the best support and performance.


Choosing the perfect running shoe in NYC requires careful consideration of your foot type, running style, and specific terrain. By following the tips and guidelines provided in this guide, we hope you’ll find the perfect pair that suits your needs and enables you to run with comfort, confidence, and enjoyment in the bustling running culture of NYC. When you are ready to start training, JFPT is here to help you along the way with an overall body analysis and personalized treatment options to make sure you reach your maximum performance level.

Happy Running!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *